I am on the verge of eligibility for retirement – holy cow - and after almost 27 years of working for the State, this prospect appeals to me. I am not leaving Austin and am not leaving the justice arena, so I will certainly see some of you professionally in the future.
It has been an enormous privilege working for Chief Justice Jefferson and the Court, working with the very talented men and women in the Office of Court Administration, and with friends I have made throughout a career in the justice system. I will miss this job and the people here a great deal, but am optimistic that the next chapter will be equally rewarding.
If you have a continuing interest in the Office of Court Administration, it looks like the next Director will be named quickly (certainly sometime in April) and in the meantime, General Counsel Mena Ramon will be the interim Director.
Take care,
Carl
Friday, March 30, 2012
Thursday, March 29, 2012
Annual Report
The Office of Court Administration and Texas Judicial Council have released the 2011 Annual Report for the Texas Judiciary, which provides synopses and highlights of court activity. Due to budget constraints, the report was not printed this year. Many people have contacted OCA to inquire about the apparent delay in this year’s publication of the Annual Report. Although the report was completed about three months later than what has been the usual in recent years, I am pleased to release the latest report. This year’s report includes new information collected from the district, statutory county, and constitutional county courts of the state and reflects years of work by OCA staff and the considerable efforts of district and county clerks and judges, case management vendors, and local information technology staff to implement changes necessitated by new Texas Judicial Council reporting requirements.
Thursday, January 26, 2012
SRLs and the Bar Part Three
Well, I learned something important yesterday and it changes my mind about a position I have taken in this debate and on this blog. Pasted below is an excerpt from the State Bar’s strategic plan for FY 2012-2013. This made me realize that I was wrong to resist the idea that the Bar should study the pro se issue, and I trust they will carry out that work as encouraged by Chief Justice Jefferson in his letter back to President Bob Black (reported yesterday by the Texas Tribune). On the other hand, I also read the below to severely undercut the position advanced by the Family Law Section/Foundation that the Access to Justice Commission, as an entity with Bar funding, is illegitimate to the extent that their efforts collaterally benefit anyone but the very poor.
In the same vein, I was also very glad to see that yesterday the Chair of the Family Law Section wrote to the membership: “Neither the Family Law Section nor the Texas Family Law Foundation have ever asked anyone to boycott Legal Aid events or withdraw support from Legal Aid organizations.”
In the same vein, I was also very glad to see that yesterday the Chair of the Family Law Section wrote to the membership: “Neither the Family Law Section nor the Texas Family Law Foundation have ever asked anyone to boycott Legal Aid events or withdraw support from Legal Aid organizations.”
STATE BAR MISSION
The mission of the State Bar of Texas is to support the administration of the legal system, assure all citizens equal access to justice, foster high standards of ethical conduct for lawyers, enable its members to better serve their clients and the public, educate the public about the rule of law and promote diversity in the administration of justice and the practice of law.
STATE BAR STRATEGIC GOALSSERVICE TO THE PUBLIC
Statement of Purpose
The State Bar of Texas serves the public by: 1) educating the public about the Rule of Law and the role of judges, lawyers, and the public in the justice system; 2) helping lawyers provide the highest quality legal and community service; and 3) working for equitable access and participation in all aspects of the justice system by diverse groups within our society.
Goals . . .
C. Assist in efforts to better focus and increase resources by systematically identifying, prioritizing and timely addressing community needs for service, as well as developing appropriate services and programs to address the needs of under-served populations and low-income Texans. . . .
G. Continue to identify and use new methods and technologies by which pro bono services training can be made accessible to more Texas lawyers.
H. Increase access to consumer legal information for the public, using new technology and media where possible to insure consumers are informed when making decisions regarding legal services.
ACCESS TO JUSTICE
Statement of Purpose
The State Bar of Texas works to ensure access to justice for all.
Goals
A. Augment pro bono services
• Explore new and innovative methods to increase the availability of pro bono legal services to low income Texans in the more remote areas of the state.
B. Build and support partnerships to increase legal services delivery –
• Educate and engage non-legal professionals who can provide relevant resources, including mediators, dispute resolution services, and CPAs.
• Interface and develop collaborative models for service delivery with other agencies providing services for the same populations.
C. Increase efforts for specialty populations –
• Work in collaboration with key partners to increase the availability and utilization of effective high quality pro se information, education, and support materials. . . .
E. Increase the visibility of pro bono efforts and access to justice issues –
• Explore and implement new methods to increase awareness and understanding among Texas lawyers and the public about access to justice issues. . . .
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
SRLs and the Bar Part Two
Here is some valuable additional information that was provided to the State Bar Board by the Access to Justice Commission.
State Responses on Standardized Forms
Commission staff has conducted extensive research on the availability of standardized forms in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. This information is a compilation of interviews with representatives from 22 states who were involved in the promulgation of their state’s forms.
1. Is there any evidence that forms have harmed the public?
• No state reported any evidence of harm to the public. Not one person interviewed knew of a litigant who had been hurt by using the standardized forms.
• States reported benefits to self-represented litigants. Many states echoed Kansas, which reported “There already were a wide number of forms being used by the public before we made our forms available. The public was downloading the forms off the internet or purchasing at local stores. Many of these are not Kansas specific and do more harm to the public than the forms we developed.”
2. What has been the impact of state forms on the ability of lawyers to earn a living?
• No state reported any evidence that the forms negatively impacted lawyers’ businesses.
• Many states reported that forms positively impacted attorney businesses.
• Maryland’s observations:
o Attorneys could attract more clients by cutting fees and having clients prepare their initial filings while the attorney focused on the more complex matters involved in the case.
o While forms and self-help centers are good at initiating a case, litigants still have challenges navigating the process, especially in contested trials and complex matters. Lawyers benefit from the state’s efforts with self-represented litigant by referring litigants to the self-help center to complete a portion of the case on their own and then recommend the litigant hire the lawyer to handle other portions.
3. Are the forms restricted to use by the poor?
• No state has restricted the use of state forms to the poor.
• All states report that the majority of litigants accessing various self-represented litigant services are low-income.
• Many states’ access to justice commissions helped develop the state’s forms.
4. What is the impact on judicial efficiency and economy?
• All states report an increase in judicial efficiency and economy.
• Susan Ledray, Senior Pro Se Services Manager, Hennepin County Courts, Minnesota, stated:
o “Forms result in the judge getting the information she needs, instead of struggling to make sense of free-form documents filed by self-represented litigants.
o Staff and judges get used to the forms and where to find the information, and this makes it faster and easier to review forms before and during hearings.
o Form blanks that are not filled in draw attention to the fact that information is missing – while with a customized pleading, the court might not realize at the most opportune time that something is lacking.
o Court staff save a lot of time when able to refer people to written forms and instructions, instead of trying to explain, write notes, or get into an unpleasant conversation with a person who is angry that ‘you won’t do your job and answer my questions.’”
• Every state indicated that pro se litigation is not increased by the promulgation of uniform forms; the forms only make the process more efficient for the courts. Nancy Strauss, Director of Judicial Council of Kansas stated, “They are going to be representing themselves anyway so we might as well give them some tools so it’s not a nightmare for all of us.”
5. How have state bars been involved in their state’s efforts to assist pro se litigants?
• A variety of state bars have been actively involved in efforts to address the problem of pro se litigants. State bars are involved in all levels of pro se programs.
• In Michigan, the self-help website is administered by the state bar.
• In the District of Columbia and Minnesota, the state bar actively promulgates and distributes uniform forms.
• Uniform forms were promulgated by the State Bar of Alabama. In 2005, the state bar appointed a task force to determine if there was a problem with self-represented litigants in the court system. The Task Force studied the issue and arrived at the conclusion that Alabama indeed did have a problem with pro se litigants. The Task Force recommended two courses of action that could be completed without a large expenditure: 1) creating standardized forms and 2) implementing a rule and other tools to further limited scope representation. The Bar approved the Task Force to proceed on creating standardized forms.
• In Oregon, it was the Family Law Section of the state bar that initially recommended that uniform forms be created. The forms were created as a joint effort between the Family Law Council, the State Court Administrator, and the State Court Advisory Committee. There are now over 300 family law forms in existence in that state.
• In addition, the American Bar Association has a pro se resource center located on their website to assist state bar associations with programs aimed at the pro se population.
6. Has the private bar opposed the promulgation of uniform forms in any organized fashion in other states?
• States like Nebraska and South Carolina, which have experienced significant opposition, involved their opponents in the process and in the end came up with better forms. Robin Wheeler, Director of the South Carolina Access to Justice Commission stated that the opponents’ “feedback was incorporated into the forms and ultimately made them better.”
• While some states indicated that there were grumblings here and there by individual attorneys or judges, the Commission’s research did not yield any other states that face organized opposition to uniform forms by the private bar.
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
School Discipline
With the roll-out last summer of the "Breaking Schools' Rules" study by the Council of State Governments Justice Center, Chief Justice Jefferson signaled his interest in a topic that has been catching on nationwide, and even "across the pond." (You can view the roll-out event from July 19, 2011, on the Supreme Court's archived webcasts, hosted by St. Mary's University School of law, here.)
Next Thursday February 2nd at 2:00 in the Supreme Court courtroom, the Texas Judicial Council's new Juvenile Justice Committee will take up the issue, with a charge to "Assess the impact of school discipline and school-based policing on referrals to the municipal, justice, and juvenile courts and identify judicial policies or initiatives that: work to reduce referrals without having a negative impact on school safety; limit recidivism; and preserve judicial resources for students who are in need of this type of intervention."
And on February 20th from 1:00-5:00, the Barbara Jordan Freedom Foundation is hosting a symposium entitled "School Discipline: A Pathway to the Juvenile Justice System or an Opportunity for Effective Intervention?" The program features Chief Justice Jefferson, Senator Whitmire, and other luminaries.
An agenda with a complete list of speakers is forthcoming and will be available at: http://www.utexas.edu/lbj/events/2012/barbara-jordan-freedom-foundation-symposium.
Next Thursday February 2nd at 2:00 in the Supreme Court courtroom, the Texas Judicial Council's new Juvenile Justice Committee will take up the issue, with a charge to "Assess the impact of school discipline and school-based policing on referrals to the municipal, justice, and juvenile courts and identify judicial policies or initiatives that: work to reduce referrals without having a negative impact on school safety; limit recidivism; and preserve judicial resources for students who are in need of this type of intervention."
And on February 20th from 1:00-5:00, the Barbara Jordan Freedom Foundation is hosting a symposium entitled "School Discipline: A Pathway to the Juvenile Justice System or an Opportunity for Effective Intervention?" The program features Chief Justice Jefferson, Senator Whitmire, and other luminaries.
An agenda with a complete list of speakers is forthcoming and will be available at: http://www.utexas.edu/lbj/events/2012/barbara-jordan-freedom-foundation-symposium.
Self-Represented Litigants and the Bar
I was disappointed but not surprised by the State Bar Board's action last Friday in response to intense lobbying by the Family Law Section/Foundation, as reported in today's Texas Tribune. I spoke at the hearing and provided some new data collected by my office that shows that 21.6% of family law matters in district and county courts in Texas are initiated by a "pro se" or self-represented petitioner. (My previous post asserted that 45% of divorce cases, a subset of all family law, are self-represented, and I stand by that estimate, which was also validated by the Travis County District Clerk's office.)
I also told the Bar Board that my national group published a paper on this topic all the way back in 2000, and that the Future Trends in State Courts publication has featured the topic of SRLs in the last five editions, so it isn't like the Access to Justice Commission just came up with this problem out of the blue. I wanted to point out, but my three minutes did not allow for it as I recall, that in fact the people who are currently using forms are mostly poor; data from TexasLawHelp shows that 62% of those who access the forms on that website earn less than $26,000 per year. (The gravamen of the Family Bar's complaint seems to be that some people who aren't poor enough to be deserving of the ATJ Commission's concern and effort will benefit from forms.)
So as reported, the Bar voted to gather data regarding the pro se issue [despite my suggestion that we have plenty of data], identify any problems presented by pro se litigants as to how courts and others are currently handling pro se litigation [despite several years of work by my office and others as noted in another prior post], and work with all stakeholders to provide potential solutions to the Supreme Court. The vote had no deadline for this work but State Bar President Bob Black - whom I like and admire although we disagree on this issue - indicated a six to nine month process. Yes, this work needs to involve all stakeholders, but I continue to believe that the problem is well documented, that several strategies to address it are well established, and that it isn't really the Bar's job, from their arguably self-interested perspective, to study the self-represented and how the court system should respond.
Yesterday an email blast went out to Texas Family Lawyers over the signature of the Chair of the Family Law Section, encouraging the members to thank the Bar Board for their vote and including the following language:
Here's hoping that there is middle ground somewhere in this mess!
I also told the Bar Board that my national group published a paper on this topic all the way back in 2000, and that the Future Trends in State Courts publication has featured the topic of SRLs in the last five editions, so it isn't like the Access to Justice Commission just came up with this problem out of the blue. I wanted to point out, but my three minutes did not allow for it as I recall, that in fact the people who are currently using forms are mostly poor; data from TexasLawHelp shows that 62% of those who access the forms on that website earn less than $26,000 per year. (The gravamen of the Family Bar's complaint seems to be that some people who aren't poor enough to be deserving of the ATJ Commission's concern and effort will benefit from forms.)
So as reported, the Bar voted to gather data regarding the pro se issue [despite my suggestion that we have plenty of data], identify any problems presented by pro se litigants as to how courts and others are currently handling pro se litigation [despite several years of work by my office and others as noted in another prior post], and work with all stakeholders to provide potential solutions to the Supreme Court. The vote had no deadline for this work but State Bar President Bob Black - whom I like and admire although we disagree on this issue - indicated a six to nine month process. Yes, this work needs to involve all stakeholders, but I continue to believe that the problem is well documented, that several strategies to address it are well established, and that it isn't really the Bar's job, from their arguably self-interested perspective, to study the self-represented and how the court system should respond.
Yesterday an email blast went out to Texas Family Lawyers over the signature of the Chair of the Family Law Section, encouraging the members to thank the Bar Board for their vote and including the following language:
The Forms Task Force is just one component in a seven-point Access to Justice Commission plan that will assist pro se litigants by re-engineering the justice system and the role of lawyers in it—using the central authority of the Supreme Court to issue a top-down order to implement the changes statewide. Our position has been and continues to be that ATJ’s seven-point plan is beyond its charter and that any such overhaul of the system should properly be led by the State Bar, its Sections, and its members.Just to get it all out there, that dire assertion appears to be based upon their reading of a document dated July 1, 2011, reproduced in full below:
Texas Access to Justice Commission
Self-Represented Litigants Committee
The Self-Represented Litigants Committee (herein “SRL Committee”) was formed in the wake of “The Texas Forum of Self-Represented Litigants and the Courts” held in April 2010. The Forum was hosted by the ATJ Special Projects Committee and co-sponsored by the Office of Court Administration, the Texas Access to Justice Foundation, the Legal Services Corporation, and the Texas Legal Services Center. Additional support was provided by the Texas Bar Foundation and the Dallas Bar Foundation.
The SRL Committee is charged with addressing the challenges presented by the increasing number of self-represented litigants interacting with Texas courts by providing tools to help pro se litigants navigate the court system.
The SRL Committee has formed six subcommittees to improve services to pro se litigants. The subcommittees are: Uniform Rules and Guidelines, Education, Self-Help Centers, Assisted Pro Se, Limited Scope Representation and Communication & Information Dissemination.That's it; six subcommittees plus a task force apparently equals a seven point ["re-engineering"] plan. If the Bar study effort forms any subcommittees, I guess the number of them will dictate the points in their plan. The dreaded "top-down order" must be a reference to the Uniform Rules and Guidelines Subcommittee, which has not come up with anything they would recommend in the way of uniform rules or legislation. Of course, there is the presenting problem, we would like the Court to adopt safe-harbor uncontested divorce forms like they already have with the Protective Order Kit. I did not hear any testimony at the Bar Board in opposition to that kit, and I would hope that it will not be attacked, but everything the family lawyers said in the hearing would apply conceptually to that prior effort.
Uniform Rules and Guidelines Subcommittee: The Uniform Rules and Guidelines Subcommittee will be recommending model court rules, legislation, and other policies to assist self-represented litigants or to clarify how various stakeholders in the court system properly interact with self-represented litigants. The Subcommittee is currently investigating which states have rules requiring their local courts to accept pleadings and orders approved by their Supreme Court. It is also researching which states have adopted a standardized policy and form on how to evaluate an Affidavit of Inability to Pay Costs filed by a self-represented litigant.
Education Subcommittee: The Education Subcommittee will inform and educate the judiciary, private bar, and the public about self-represented litigant issues, and how to more effectively serve self-represented litigants. The Subcommittee is currently devising a workshop for members of the judiciary and court personnel. This training will eventually be conducted in all nine administrative judicial regions. Clerks and court staff will be trained on how to provide legal information while remaining impartial, maintaining confidential information, and avoiding ex parte communications. Further, participants will be taught the critical difference between legal advice and legal information. The Subcommittee is also working on a series of workshops to be given to new local bar leaders at the annual Local Bar Leaders Conference held by the State Bar of Texas in Houston this July.
Self-Help Center Subcommittee: The Self-Help Center and Services Subcommittee is working towards expanding the quantity and quality of self-help centers across the state. The Subcommittee is currently assembling a comprehensive list of self-help centers and assessing what kind of technical assistance these centers need to more effectively serve litigants attempting to represent themselves.
Assisted Pro Se Subcommittee: The Assisted Pro Se Subcommittee is working towards expanding the availability of legal services for pro se litigants. Specifically, how legal service or pro bono attorneys can help pro se litigants represent themselves in court, including preparing pleadings and other court forms, advising which course of action to take, and preparing for hearings.
Limited Scope Representation: In conjunction with the Rules Subcommittee, the Limited Scope Representation Subcommittee will draft rules to allow attorneys to more easily assist people on a limited scope basis. The subcommittee will work with the private bar to help attorneys understand what limited scope representation is and how to go about developing it as a new business model of practice.
Communications and Information Dissemination Subcommittee: The Communications and Information Dissemination Subcommittee is developing a plan of how to effectively communicate with the judiciary, private bar, and the public about the self-represented litigant issues. The subcommittee will also create a clearinghouse of information regarding SRL initiatives and resources.
Supreme Court Uniform Forms Task Force: The Task Force is charged with developing proposed pleading and order forms, to be evaluated and approved by the Court, with the express purpose of enabling the courts to help pro se litigants navigate the legal system and improve court efficiencies. The Task Force meets on a monthly basis and is working on basic family law forms for a divorce without children. The Task Force is set to complete these pleadings and forms by September 2011.
Here's hoping that there is middle ground somewhere in this mess!
Wednesday, January 11, 2012
Shared Solutions Summit
In the first “Shared Solutions Summit” this week in Austin, judges, clerks, prosecutors, attorneys and others involved in the courts across Texas shared best practices and procedures for handling criminal, child protection, juvenile and civil cases.
The conference and other that follow, led by Chief Justice Wallace B. Jefferson, promotes the exercise of judicial leadership at the local level, the use of data-driven strategies, and a collaborative approach to ensure that cases are disposed efficiently and with improved outcomes.
For example, Bell County courts, serving a Fort Hood population, see a high volume of divorce matters and high percentage of self-represented litigants. They already have some good procedures but at the Summit identified the idea, from Lubbock, of developing a video to orient litigants. The Fannin County team worked on enhancing their mental health diversion court, with new ideas for grant funding, and an offer to learn more from Judge Susan Hawk’s Dallas County mental health court. Conference evaluations praised the ability to interact within teams, with other teams, and with people who have “done it” and were willing to share their experience.
“This whole conference is about courts, and courts are devised for helping people with their sometimes critical problems,” Chief Justice Jefferson said. “These all-too-real human problems present major cost and management problems for all of us in the courts – and for the people of Texas. And while justice is a tiny fraction of the state budget, it is a major component of local budgets.”
As leaders working to assure justice in the state’s communities, he said, the participants in this summit show their determination to make courts work better by attending.
The Shared Solutions Summit was started by Chief Justice Jefferson and the Texas Judicial Council, a policymaking body which he chairs. The Texas Conference of Urban Counties provided primary financing, with financial or substantive support from the Court of Criminal Appeals, the Supreme Court Children’s Commission, the Texas Indigent Defense Commission, the Judicial Committee on Information Technology, the Texas Municipal Courts Education Center, the Texas Center for the Judiciary, the Texas Association of Counties, the Texas Access to Justice Commission, the National Center for State Courts, the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges and the State Justice Institute. Jefferson hopes to offer the program to a new group of local teams at least every other year.
The conference and other that follow, led by Chief Justice Wallace B. Jefferson, promotes the exercise of judicial leadership at the local level, the use of data-driven strategies, and a collaborative approach to ensure that cases are disposed efficiently and with improved outcomes.
For example, Bell County courts, serving a Fort Hood population, see a high volume of divorce matters and high percentage of self-represented litigants. They already have some good procedures but at the Summit identified the idea, from Lubbock, of developing a video to orient litigants. The Fannin County team worked on enhancing their mental health diversion court, with new ideas for grant funding, and an offer to learn more from Judge Susan Hawk’s Dallas County mental health court. Conference evaluations praised the ability to interact within teams, with other teams, and with people who have “done it” and were willing to share their experience.
“This whole conference is about courts, and courts are devised for helping people with their sometimes critical problems,” Chief Justice Jefferson said. “These all-too-real human problems present major cost and management problems for all of us in the courts – and for the people of Texas. And while justice is a tiny fraction of the state budget, it is a major component of local budgets.”
As leaders working to assure justice in the state’s communities, he said, the participants in this summit show their determination to make courts work better by attending.
The Shared Solutions Summit was started by Chief Justice Jefferson and the Texas Judicial Council, a policymaking body which he chairs. The Texas Conference of Urban Counties provided primary financing, with financial or substantive support from the Court of Criminal Appeals, the Supreme Court Children’s Commission, the Texas Indigent Defense Commission, the Judicial Committee on Information Technology, the Texas Municipal Courts Education Center, the Texas Center for the Judiciary, the Texas Association of Counties, the Texas Access to Justice Commission, the National Center for State Courts, the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges and the State Justice Institute. Jefferson hopes to offer the program to a new group of local teams at least every other year.
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
State Jail Diligent Participation
In 2007, when I was using the name CourTex for a quarterly newsletter, I wrote a special issue on state sentencing, and said this (p. 4) about the state jail innovation:
TDCJ's website has the following page with discussion and a link to further instructions, http://tdcj.state.tx.us/divisions/cid/cid_support_ops_class_HB2649.html, and this page can also be reached by clicking on the Online Services Tab on the TDCJ home page, http://tdcj.state.tx.us/ then choosing State Jail Diligent Participation towards the bottom of that page.
[A] correctional agency has an inherent interest in maintaining some otherwised unpopular features in state sentencing laws - good conduct time and parole - that provide "back end discretion" and therefore some behavioral incentive during incarceration. This is the enduring lesson of the state jail scheme, which does not provide any such incentive, and has proved challenging to implement as a result.Now that issue has been addressed by the legislature, and in turn by TDCJ. In order to provide an incentive for state jail felons to participate in rehabilitation in accordance with HB 2649 from the 82nd Legislature, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice will provide a progress report to the sentencing judge, which will include information such as name, date of birth, offense, sentence begin date, current discharge date, and diligent participation days. The sentencing judge may credit up to 20% of the offender's sentence for days served as long as the offender was diligently participating in a program and not subject to disciplinary action.
TDCJ's website has the following page with discussion and a link to further instructions, http://tdcj.state.tx.us/divisions/cid/cid_support_ops_class_HB2649.html, and this page can also be reached by clicking on the Online Services Tab on the TDCJ home page, http://tdcj.state.tx.us/ then choosing State Jail Diligent Participation towards the bottom of that page.
Thursday, December 22, 2011
Courts Are Not Revenue Centers
As foreshadowed recently, the COSCA Policy Paper for 2011, "Courts Are Not Revenue Centers," is now available online. My thanks to the Policy & Liaison Committee of COSCA, and the always helpful and skilled staff of the National Center for State Courts.
When I became director of OCA in April 2005, we were in the middle of legislative session, and it was all about money, what a surprise. My small agency's part in the drama, accounting for the first several meetings I attended, was about legislation to require large jurisdictions to follow a model collection improvement program that OCA had devised for voluntary adoption. The program was aimed at collecting the myriad costs that are imposed on conviction of a criminal offense. Of course, the purpose of the legislation was to maximize state revenue, and I only learned later about the conversations behind the scenes, where the expected additional revenue was being earmarked for various purposes, some more appropriate than others. This was my introduction to the world of court costs and fees in our state, a topic that has necessarily become much more familiar over time, leading up to my keen interest in developing this newest Policy Paper (formerly "White Paper") for COSCA.
The paper has six parts, including an introduction, definitions and a conclusion, so I am going to focus here on the meaty middle three parts. Two of them are devoted to case law from the states, and I confess that is one thing that appealed to me about this topic; both chiefs and administrators share in this issue. The first of these, Part Three of the paper, addresses the open courts problem of creating too high a barrier to filing a case by imposing filing fees in civil cases, citing cases from Texas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Alabama, Florida, Arizona and Illinois. As stated by my favorite court, the theme of that section is "If the right to obtain justice freely is to be a meaningful guarantee, it must preclude the legislature from raising general welfare through charges assessed to those who would utilize our courts."
Part Four addresses the corollary problem, a separation of powers problem, of heaping costs and surcharges upon those convicted. Cases from Wyoming, Michigan, Virginia, Arkansas and Missouri are added to the mix. Most courts agree that costs imposed must bear a reasonable relationship to the expenses of prosecution, but courts vary widely in their application of this test.
In Part Five, we have refined and reasserted as principles a set of standards governing court costs and fees, ostensible standards that were adopted by COSCA thirty years ago. In your handout, the last page is a restatement of just those seven standards, couched as statements of policy, so you can take a look if you haven't had a chance to digest the paper. A couple are uncontroversial or so clearly based on constitutional law that they are incontestable. Others you may find more challenging, particularly as you get into the specific history and system in a given state. The committee clearly acknowledges the tension between principles and the realities we all face, but offers the policy statements as guideposts to direct reasoned conversation and the balance of competing interests.
The bottom line: Courts are not revenue centers. That is the title of this year's policy paper, and it goes to the heart of the aspiration that the Policy and Liaison Committee espouses. Because people are compelled to use the courts on occasion, there is a strong pull toward a user fee mentality, and we all feel it. But there are several problems that flow from viewing the courts as revenue centers. The three major ones are unfathomable complexity, unfair financial burdens on those unable to meet them, and inappropriate, even unconstitutional, fund allocation.
I first experienced the unfathomable complexity of the Texas regime back in 2005. That's when I learned that one of my lawyers, Ted Wood, understands the system and publishes guides for clerks, available on Texas Courts Online under the topic "For Trial Courts." Take a look at the documents under Filing Fees and Costs, to get an idea of one state's complexity.
But here in Texas I get the sense that the complexity is less of a concern to legislators than the growing impact on those who pay, and the growing sense that these are taxes by another name. Last session we tried to save indigent defense and legal services with new court costs and fees, and were rejected on that basis.
What I propose is to take this paper to our Judicial Council, and begin to formulate a new cost and fee system, built from the ground up. I want to focus on the clearly legitimate court funds that are fed by costs and fees, and work our way out in both directions from there. See what fees feed into those funds and simplify their structure and administration. And, see what court services are funded, and what else is funded with court revenue, to see if we can provoke a consensus on finding other money to take care of the executive branch programs that currently feed off the courts.
Last session I told the appropriations committee that the courts in Texas generate $450 million for the state, and the state spends $300 million on the courts. Next session I hope we can bring those numbers into a better alignment, but without tying the courts to revenue they generate. It is a difficult and dicey proposition, but as our paper advocates, state court leaders should each try to take on this problem in our respective states.
Tuesday, December 20, 2011
Terms of Court and Grand Juries - Correction
The bad news is, whoops. The good news is, I have been advised that a pre-existing statute in our large garden of laws of court should cover the concern raised in my previous post:
Govt Code Sec. 24.018. CERTAIN EFFECT OF DISTRICT REORGANIZATION. If the counties that compose a judicial district or the time or place for holding terms of a district court are changed by law:
(1) the process and writs issued from the district court and made returnable to a term of court fixed by the law at the time of the issuance are returnable to the next term of the court as fixed by the amended law and are as legal and valid as if they were made returnable to the term of the court as fixed by the amended law;
(2) the grand and petit jurors selected or drawn under the prior law in any county in the judicial district are lawfully selected or drawn for the next term of the district court of the county as fixed by the amended law; and
(3) the obligees in all appearance bonds and recognizances taken in and for the district court and the witnesses summoned to appear before the district court under the prior law are required to appear at the next term of the court as fixed by the amended law.
Friday, December 16, 2011
Terms of Court and Grand Juries
Judges of Texas, please take note, this is an issue that you may not be aware of and it is important!
HB 79, the Court Reorganization bill from the First Called Session, contains a provision (Sec. 3.03 of the bill) establishing two terms of court each year in every district court in the state. The first term of court begins on the first Monday in January. The second term of court begins on the first Monday in July. Each term of court continues until the day on which the succeeding term of court begins.
The provision – codified as Government Code, Section 24.012 – becomes effective January 1, 2012. HB 79 does not address the transition from the system of terms of court under current law to the new terms of court.
Under current law, different district courts have different terms of court. The terms of court in a particular district court are established by the statute creating the court. For example, the 174th District Court of Harris County has four terms of court each year. See Texas Government Code, Section 24.267. Those terms begin on the first Mondays in February, May, August, and November.
Section 24.012 states that the new general rule will control over the current specific provisions. Accordingly, all district courts will have the same two terms of court each year. We believe that all terms of court established under existing law will come to an end on Sunday, January 1. The new system of two terms of court each year will begin the next day.
Terms of court are significant with respect to grand juries. Grand juries are impaneled to serve for a particular term of court. The new law raises a question about grand juries that are in the middle of a current term of court on January 1. The specific question is whether such a grand jury retains the power to act until the end of the originally-scheduled end of that term.
We believe the answer is no. We believe that when the term of court ends, the power of the grand jury ends. The only exception would be an extension of the grand jury’s term under Article 19.07 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Such an extension, however, can only be made to allow for the conclusion of an investigation of matters presently before the grand jury. The grand jury is not authorized to consider new matters.
HB 79, the Court Reorganization bill from the First Called Session, contains a provision (Sec. 3.03 of the bill) establishing two terms of court each year in every district court in the state. The first term of court begins on the first Monday in January. The second term of court begins on the first Monday in July. Each term of court continues until the day on which the succeeding term of court begins.
The provision – codified as Government Code, Section 24.012 – becomes effective January 1, 2012. HB 79 does not address the transition from the system of terms of court under current law to the new terms of court.
Under current law, different district courts have different terms of court. The terms of court in a particular district court are established by the statute creating the court. For example, the 174th District Court of Harris County has four terms of court each year. See Texas Government Code, Section 24.267. Those terms begin on the first Mondays in February, May, August, and November.
Section 24.012 states that the new general rule will control over the current specific provisions. Accordingly, all district courts will have the same two terms of court each year. We believe that all terms of court established under existing law will come to an end on Sunday, January 1. The new system of two terms of court each year will begin the next day.
Terms of court are significant with respect to grand juries. Grand juries are impaneled to serve for a particular term of court. The new law raises a question about grand juries that are in the middle of a current term of court on January 1. The specific question is whether such a grand jury retains the power to act until the end of the originally-scheduled end of that term.
We believe the answer is no. We believe that when the term of court ends, the power of the grand jury ends. The only exception would be an extension of the grand jury’s term under Article 19.07 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Such an extension, however, can only be made to allow for the conclusion of an investigation of matters presently before the grand jury. The grand jury is not authorized to consider new matters.
Monday, November 28, 2011
COSCA White Papers
As I pointed out in 2010, my national group, the Conference of State Court Administrators (COSCA) issues a policy paper each year, known to many as the "COSCA White Paper." Working on racial
disproportionality in child welfare and other systems has sensitized us to the
freighted significance of such terminology. We now refer to it as a Policy
Paper, for that is what we hope the Policy & Liaison committee will produce, a statement of
provocative and helpful policy guidance for the leaders of the states'
court systems. As the current chair of that committee, I hope to release the newest paper, "Courts Are Not Revenue Centers," in the very near future. In the meantime I thought it would be helpful to share a compilation of the last decade-plus worth of very good papers:
Self-Represented Litigation (2000)
Access to Court Records (2000)
Wednesday, November 2, 2011
Grant Award to Lone Star Legal Aid
Readers of this blog have seen a number of posts on civil access to justice, the self- or un-represented, and related topics, topics of sustained interest for me and many in my work world. Today I am pleased to echo the announcement that Lone Star Legal Aid, in partnership with the Texas Legal Services Center and OCA, received a grant award from the Legal Services Corporation's TIG (Technology Improvement Grant) program. As described in this excerpt from their press release on a total of $3.6 million in grants:
LSC-funded programs are overwhelmed with requests for civil legal assistance, in part because of the economy. Courts—especially housing and family courts—have seen an increase in the number of low-income individuals without a lawyer. Studies in several states have found that about 80 percent of the legal needs of low-income families go unmet.This topic always reminds me of an excellent 2005 report that I've saved, called "Civil Legal Assistance for All Americans," by Jeanne Charn and Richard Zorza. It has seemed to me that the full access vision they espouse should be a template for our work in Texas, with the Census bureau recently documenting the increase of people living in poverty in our state, from 4.26 million to 4.63 million. Charn and Zorza advocate a full-access legal system with the following foundational principles:
The systems that LSC-funded programs use to conduct client intake—most often telephone hotlines and in-person interviews—are often swamped by requests for legal services, frustrating clients and programs. The new round of technology grants continue efforts to develop new, user-friendly online intake systems for clients who need alternatives that permit the filing of applications for legal assistance outside normal business hours. . . .
In an effort to help people who must navigate courts without a lawyer, Lone Star Legal Aid will undertake a project to merge Texas Law Help, which provides self-help forms, and Texas Courts Online, which offers information about the state court system. The project will create a one-stop, easy-to-understand information source and include Spanish and Vietnamese translations of legal forms.
Scope and Coverage of a Full-Access Legal Services SystemI hope that we can have a rational conversation here in Texas and pursue a vision that will provide justice for all.
Consumer Assurances and Responsibilities
- An expanded delivery system should serve moderate- as well as low-income people.
- The types of legal needs for which assistance will be provided should be defined as a matter of policy. Specific service priorities, within broad categories, should be determined locally.
- Consumers will be entitled to advice and assistance, but an attorney’s services should be available only when lawyers provide the highest-quality and most cost-effective response.
Provider Diversity and Innovation
- Consumers should have a choice of providers appropriate to meet covered needs.
- An expanded delivery system should be consumer-driven, clientcentered and holistic.
- An expanded delivery system should protect representation of unpopular claims and insulate funders from the appearance of interference with service to individual clients.
- Consumers should be responsible for copayments for many services as well as reimbursement of out-of-pocket costs related to service.
- Courts and administrative agencies should reform their rules and processes and provide information and assistance in order to reduce, wherever possible, the need for full-service attorneys.
- The private bar should be the first resource for low- and moderate income people with legal needs.
- Private attorneys should have opportunities to provide service, on a paid basis, when they are a cost-effective and high-quality option.
- Paralegals should provide service in all areas permitted under existing rules. Policymakers and bar leaders should support expanded paralegal practice with appropriate quality assurances and consumer protections.
- Technology should be fully deployed to deliver assistance directly to consumers and as an integral part of the infrastructure of a full-access delivery system.
Thursday, October 20, 2011
Workers' Compensation
I realize the ABA is viewed as liberal in general and plaintiff-oriented in civil matters, so caveat emptor. I am a member and I read their magazine, as well as the criminal justice section magazine, which, on another topic of interest in my world, has an article in the most recent issue on Eliminating Excessive Public Defender Workloads.
The ABA Journal recently ran a pretty scathing article on the Texas Workers' Compensation System; here is a thematic sentence:
The ABA Journal recently ran a pretty scathing article on the Texas Workers' Compensation System; here is a thematic sentence:
[S]everal decades of tweaking—through legislation, policy and business practices mostly meant to target scams by physicians and medical services providers—have gone beyond simple reform. Critics of the system say it has become so hostile, so skewed toward delay and denial that lawyers, physicians and even legitimate claimants have been driven away.This is a topic that I have been around, working in the legislature back in the late 1980s/early 1990s, and I know several of the people who were intimately involved in the machinations back then, but it has never been an area of actual understanding on my part. (So I confess my ignorance.) But I found the article troubling and compelling, and if I were a legislator I might be stirred to attempted action. But in my actual role, what interests me most is the removal of matters of dispute from the system that is contemplated by our three-branch system of government, the courts. Here is a chart from OCA data that succinctly tells that story.
Friday, October 14, 2011
Judicial Compensation
The reporting on the Texas Department of Transportation's new director's compensation prompts me to point out the stunning disparity between the numbers under discussion there and the compensation we pay to judges in particular (not to mention other public servants such as yours truly), and the Chief Justice in particular. The prior director of TxDOT (an engineer) received $192,500 per year and the TxDOT board wants to pay the new gentleman (an MBA) $381,000, but according to today's Statesman, he will have to settle for only $292,500. I hope that he will feel better knowing that the latter at least puts him one step closer to the top of the comparables list that the Judicial Compensation Commission published (based on the General Appropriations Act) as Table 10 in their most recent (2010) report, which has these figures for "Salaries of State Constitutional, Elected and Other High-Ranking Executive Office Holders":
And for the record, after 26 years of state service as a lawyer, general counsel and now agency director, I make $130,000 and feel privileged to make that kind of money in this economy, get to do what I do, and work for Chief Justice Jefferson.
Executive Director: Employees Retirement System $300,000The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas, and the Presiding Judge of the Court of Criminal Appeals, are paid $152,500. (The Commission's report recommended increasing that amount to $168,000 but of course there was no serious talk of judicial pay raises during the last session.) Other Texas judges' salaries go down from there, except for some county court at law judges whose locally-supplemented pay puts them above their arguably higher-ranked district and appellate brethren.
Executive Commissioner: Health and Human Services $210,000
Executive Director: Department of Transportation $192,500
Commissioner: Texas Education Agency $186,300
Executive Director: Department of Criminal Justice $186,300
Commissioner: Department of State Health Services $183,750
Executive Director: Department of Information Resources $175,000
Executive Director: Department of Public Safety $162,000
Executive Director: Texas Youth Commission $160,000
Comptroller of Public Accounts $150,000
Attorney General $150,000
Governor $150,000
Executive Director: Commission on Environmental Quality $145,200
Agriculture Commissioner $137,500
Commissioner of the General Land Office $137,500
Railroad Commissioner $137,500
Secretary of State $125,880
Average $169,966
Median $169,000
And for the record, after 26 years of state service as a lawyer, general counsel and now agency director, I make $130,000 and feel privileged to make that kind of money in this economy, get to do what I do, and work for Chief Justice Jefferson.
Thursday, October 13, 2011
Capital Punishment
At the request of Senator Carona's staff, a few days ago I was privileged to meet with an international group, including members of parliament from Sri Lanka and Nepal. Inevitably, the conversation turned to capital punishment in Texas, and I told them that imposition of the death penalty has gone down fairly dramatically in recent years. Later on I wanted to fact check myself and asked our amazing Judicial Information manager, Angela Garcia, to run this graph for me from our data.
In addition to reassuring me that I told them correctly, one thing I find interesting about this graph is the fact that life without parole was not adopted until 2005 (S.B. 60 by Lucio), but the downward trend was well established well before then. My other thought was, "how much of this trend is driven by Harris County?" TDCJ's information shows that 106 of 308 offenders on death row are from Harris County. Here is what OCA data shows over time.
Finally, in direct comparison to the first chart, here is what our data shows for Harris County's choice of the death penalty versus other punishment in capital cases.
In addition to reassuring me that I told them correctly, one thing I find interesting about this graph is the fact that life without parole was not adopted until 2005 (S.B. 60 by Lucio), but the downward trend was well established well before then. My other thought was, "how much of this trend is driven by Harris County?" TDCJ's information shows that 106 of 308 offenders on death row are from Harris County. Here is what OCA data shows over time.
Finally, in direct comparison to the first chart, here is what our data shows for Harris County's choice of the death penalty versus other punishment in capital cases.
Sunday, October 2, 2011
Leadership, Collaboration, and Data
In September I had the privilege of addressing the Annual Judicial Conference, on changes facing the judiciary. Two themes were the growing significance of litigants presenting special challenges - children, the unrepresented, the Limited English Proficient, the mentally impaired, the elderly, and so on; and the diminishing significance of tort litigation as part of the state court caseload. I suggested that judges embrace their growing role as gatekeepers to services and sorters of troubled humanity, and that they should expect, and be expected, to operate as problem-solving judges and not only in the traditional, adversarial mold.
A great resource for judges on how to facilitate positive change and achieve better outcomes, is "Building a Better Collaboration - Facilitating Change in the Court and Child Welfare System," an NCJFCJ Technical Assistance Bulletin, which is not available online to my knowledge. In addition to basics of child welfare law, the book goes through learning organizations ala Peter Senge; leadership in general and judicial leadership in particular; creating a collaborative, problem-solving culture; using effective meetings and communication; the importance of data and evaluation; and the strategic achievement of planning, effecting and sustaining change. It is a digestible and yet complete guide to what we know about moving groups of well-meaning humans through a deliberative and synergistic process of improvement. For the Shared Solutions Summit and in general when pondering this work, I boil down the method into Leadership, [multidisciplinary] Collaboration, and Data.
A great resource for judges on how to facilitate positive change and achieve better outcomes, is "Building a Better Collaboration - Facilitating Change in the Court and Child Welfare System," an NCJFCJ Technical Assistance Bulletin, which is not available online to my knowledge. In addition to basics of child welfare law, the book goes through learning organizations ala Peter Senge; leadership in general and judicial leadership in particular; creating a collaborative, problem-solving culture; using effective meetings and communication; the importance of data and evaluation; and the strategic achievement of planning, effecting and sustaining change. It is a digestible and yet complete guide to what we know about moving groups of well-meaning humans through a deliberative and synergistic process of improvement. For the Shared Solutions Summit and in general when pondering this work, I boil down the method into Leadership, [multidisciplinary] Collaboration, and Data.
Monday, September 26, 2011
Race and Risk II
At the beginning of the month I introduced Donald Baumann on this topic of continuing interest, and have been in contact with him since then. Here is Donn's response to my post, setting out his view of the current state of the data.
"Over-representation comes from several sources and we have evidence for some of them. According to the latest National Incidence Study (NIS 4), African American families are more likely to maltreat their children under certain conditions. However, if you look closely at the Texas CPS data on substantiated maltreatment, controlling for poverty, single parenthood, young parents, number of children and other factors, a picture of racial bias emerges.
What we find is that even at lower levels of risk of future maltreatment (which includes prior reporting), workers are more likely to substantiate African Americans than Anglos. What this means is that both bias and maltreatment may play a part in all of this but no one knows what that part is. In our view, poverty is the key because it is viewed differently for African Americans than it is for Anglos and, as a result, the threshold for substantiation is lower for African Americans than Anglos. At present, however, no one knows what features of poverty are related to substantiated maltreatment and what are related to bias.
One major source of over-representation that we know about is the higher reporting rates for African Americans, relative to Anglos. This higher rate appears to move through what we refer to as the CPS Decision-Making Continuum from intake to service provision and placement of children into care. Thus, some of the higher rates of disproportionality results from reporting and that contribution to disproportionality continues to move through the system.
So why is there so much disproportionality at reporting? Some have argued that people who are low income are often under greater scrutiny through their contacts with social service programs, increased law enforcement in low-income neighborhoods, etc., so this likely increases reporting about these families - thus, we can't say with certainty whether "repeated contacts" are truly indicative of greater rates of maltreatment among African Americans or of unidentified maltreatment among other racial groups.
Others have argued from data such as infant mortality rates that the reporting rates appear similar to the fatality rates and, because the latter is not as subject to bias as reporting rates, the reporting rates are real.
Finally, we don't know much about the potential for reporting bias. It may be that, much like the substantiation decision, the decision to report contains some disparate features that are related to actual maltreatment and some that are related to bias.
Another source of over-representation is decision-making bias that contributes to the higher rates of placements into care for African American children relative to Anglos and the lower rates of reunification for African American children relative to Anglo children. Regarding the latter two sources (flow in and out of the system) we controlled for the same factors as above for substantiation and; in the case of reunification, drug abuse and inadequate housing are additional factors that are controlled for.
Our findings are similar to those with regard to substantiation. What this means is that both underlying risk of maltreatment and racial bias play a part in how cases flow in and out of the CPS system of care and disproportionality is the result."
"Over-representation comes from several sources and we have evidence for some of them. According to the latest National Incidence Study (NIS 4), African American families are more likely to maltreat their children under certain conditions. However, if you look closely at the Texas CPS data on substantiated maltreatment, controlling for poverty, single parenthood, young parents, number of children and other factors, a picture of racial bias emerges.
What we find is that even at lower levels of risk of future maltreatment (which includes prior reporting), workers are more likely to substantiate African Americans than Anglos. What this means is that both bias and maltreatment may play a part in all of this but no one knows what that part is. In our view, poverty is the key because it is viewed differently for African Americans than it is for Anglos and, as a result, the threshold for substantiation is lower for African Americans than Anglos. At present, however, no one knows what features of poverty are related to substantiated maltreatment and what are related to bias.
One major source of over-representation that we know about is the higher reporting rates for African Americans, relative to Anglos. This higher rate appears to move through what we refer to as the CPS Decision-Making Continuum from intake to service provision and placement of children into care. Thus, some of the higher rates of disproportionality results from reporting and that contribution to disproportionality continues to move through the system.
So why is there so much disproportionality at reporting? Some have argued that people who are low income are often under greater scrutiny through their contacts with social service programs, increased law enforcement in low-income neighborhoods, etc., so this likely increases reporting about these families - thus, we can't say with certainty whether "repeated contacts" are truly indicative of greater rates of maltreatment among African Americans or of unidentified maltreatment among other racial groups.
Others have argued from data such as infant mortality rates that the reporting rates appear similar to the fatality rates and, because the latter is not as subject to bias as reporting rates, the reporting rates are real.
Finally, we don't know much about the potential for reporting bias. It may be that, much like the substantiation decision, the decision to report contains some disparate features that are related to actual maltreatment and some that are related to bias.
Another source of over-representation is decision-making bias that contributes to the higher rates of placements into care for African American children relative to Anglos and the lower rates of reunification for African American children relative to Anglo children. Regarding the latter two sources (flow in and out of the system) we controlled for the same factors as above for substantiation and; in the case of reunification, drug abuse and inadequate housing are additional factors that are controlled for.
Our findings are similar to those with regard to substantiation. What this means is that both underlying risk of maltreatment and racial bias play a part in how cases flow in and out of the CPS system of care and disproportionality is the result."
Friday, September 23, 2011
Collection Improvement - and Job Postings
Collection of court costs is an important reflection of respect for the rule of law, and an important revenue source for many programs, and I have written briefly on the topic previously. We describe OCA's collection improvement program in the Texas Administrative Code (1 TAC 175.1) thus:
1. I have the authority to grant a waiver to a county for whom the program is actually not cost effective, and am willing to talk through what that computation might look like, and grant a waiver(s) if justified.
2. We have spelled out the program in great detail through the Administrative Code, and the APA says you can petition an agency for the revision of rules, but no one has requested revisions. Stay tuned for the possibility of refinements that we propose, and an opportunity to comment on those or upon the rules otherwise.
Finally, it is important to note that the Legislature has given OCA responsibility for auditing local compliance with this program (a function formerly assigned to the Comptroller). We have an opening posted and have conducted interviews for a Managing Auditor, and will be posting additional openings for this program in the near future.
The OCA Collection Improvement Program applies to criminal cases in which the defendant agrees to or is required to pay all court costs, fees, and fines under a payment plan rather than when they are assessed and payment is requested. Although the program can be utilized by a judge in virtually every criminal case to effectuate the judge’s financial orders, it is not designed to influence the judicial determination of whether to order payment of costs, fees and fines, or otherwise to affect the sentencing or other disposition decision that is within the judge’s discretion. The program is simply designed to improve the collection of court costs, fees and fines that have been imposed, while helping defendants satisfy their obligations. The program is not intended to conflict with or undermine the provision to defendants of full procedural and substantive rights under the constitution and laws of this state and of the United States.For the full text of the existing rule, and considerably more information about the program, visit the website. With a few new counties entering the program due to the 2010 census, we want to make sure that folks are aware of the program, but also that local officials realize two things:
1. I have the authority to grant a waiver to a county for whom the program is actually not cost effective, and am willing to talk through what that computation might look like, and grant a waiver(s) if justified.
2. We have spelled out the program in great detail through the Administrative Code, and the APA says you can petition an agency for the revision of rules, but no one has requested revisions. Stay tuned for the possibility of refinements that we propose, and an opportunity to comment on those or upon the rules otherwise.
Finally, it is important to note that the Legislature has given OCA responsibility for auditing local compliance with this program (a function formerly assigned to the Comptroller). We have an opening posted and have conducted interviews for a Managing Auditor, and will be posting additional openings for this program in the near future.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Small Claims Cases
Just about the only controversial feature of the major court reorganization bill, HB 79, 2nd Called Session (and SB 1717 during Regular Session) was the repeal of Chapter 28 Government Code, which designates justices of the peace as small claims courts, to be replaced with a single body of procedural requirements for civil cases in JP court, be they small claims or otherwise. Article 5 of HB 79 is the operative portion, and this is the major new provision:
Sec. 27.060. SMALL CLAIMS. (a) A justice court shall conduct proceedings in a small claims case, as that term is defined by the supreme court, in accordance with rules of civil procedure promulgated by the supreme court to ensure the fair, expeditious, and inexpensive resolution of small claims cases.
Last week the court issued an order creating the new task force, which looks like an excellent group. It is my unofficial understanding that the first meeting will be held on October 26th in Austin.
(b) Except as provided by Subsection (c), rules of the supreme court must provide that:
(1) if both parties appear, the judge shall proceed to hear the case;
(2) formal pleadings other than the statement are not required;
(3) the judge shall hear the testimony of the parties and the witnesses that the parties produce and shall consider the other evidence offered;
(4) the hearing is informal, with the sole objective being to dispense speedy justice between the parties;
(5) discovery is limited to that considered appropriate and permitted by the judge; and
(6) the judge shall develop the facts of the case, and for that purpose may question a witness or party and may summon any party to appear as a witness as the judge considers necessary to a correct judgment and speedy disposition of the case.
(c) The rules of the supreme court must provide specific procedures for an action by:
(1) an assignee of a claim or other person seeking to bring an action on an assigned claim;
(2) a person primarily engaged in the business of lending money at interest; or
(3) a collection agency or collection agent.
(d) The rules adopted by the supreme court may not:
(1) require that a party in a case be represented by an attorney;
(2) be so complex that a reasonable person without legal training would have difficulty understanding or applying the rules; or
(3) require that discovery rules adopted under the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure or the Texas Rules of Evidence be applied except to the extent the justice of the peace hearing the case determines that the rules must be followed to ensure that the proceeding is fair to all parties.
(e) A committee established by the supreme court to recommend rules to be adopted under this section must include justices of the peace.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)